USA - Do Farm Subsidies Reduce Rural Poverty?

24.01.2017 666 views
Rural voters played an important role in the last election. As the Senate considers a new Secretary of Agriculture and Congress begins work on a new Farm Bill, it’s important to consider the effect that food and farm policy has on rural communities, especially those that are impoverished. Farm lobbyists frequently insist that farm subsidies are critically important to supporting the rural economy. “It's not so much a safety net for farmers as it keeps rural America alive,” said one proponent of corn subsidies. “Agriculture forms the lifeblood of many rural communities,” according to an advocate for cotton farmers. So, according to the logic of these farm lobbyists, farm subsidies are “crucial to the economic security of rural America.” Even modest cuts to subsidies for “Cadillac” crop insurance policies would “[hit] rural America where it hurts most,” according to Senate Agriculture Committee Chairman Pat Roberts. The truth is that farm subsidies play little role in reducing rural poverty. That’s according to a paper by three leading agriculture economists commissioned by the American Enterprise Institute, or AEI. It confirms the findings of a 2013 paper by other leading economists. Here’s why. Farm subsidies overwhelmingly flow to the largest producers of bulk commodities, so “these benefits are mainly distributed to large commercial-sized farms,” wrote the authors the of AEI-sponsored paper. According to EWG’s Farm Subsidy Database, 77 percent of farm subsidies paid between 1995 and 2014 flowed to the largest 10 percent of subsidy recipients. The top 1 percent of subsidy recipients received 26 percent of all payments. As a result, roughly 30,000 very large farm businesses have received more than $46 billion in subsidy payments – or $1.57 million per farm – over the last two decades. While some very large operations receive more than $1 million annually in subsidies, the bottom 80 percent of subsidy recipients annually collect less than $10,000. “While farm subsidies transfer income from taxpayers to farm owners, most of the direct beneficiaries are relatively wealthy,” the economists concluded. The median wealth of the nation’s 50,000 largest commercial farms is $6.9 million, according to the USDA’s Economic Research Service. What’s more, many subsidies also flow to urban residents, not farmers – including the Trump administration’s nominee for Secretary of Agriculture, former Georgia Gov. Sonny Perdue. According to EWG’s Farm Subsidy Database, between 1995 and 2004 Purdue collected $278,000 in farm subsidies, even though he is not a farmer. Purdue owns farms – which he leases to farmers – and ran businesses that sell fertilizer and store grain. But EWG could find no evidence that Purdue has been a farmer since he left his family’s farm for college more than 50 years ago. Thousands of city slickers like Purdue continue to collect farm subsidies. But these are not the only reasons why subsidies do not reduce rural poverty. Farming accounts for only 6 percent of employment in non-metropolitan counties – employing far fewer people than transportation, utilities, manufacturing and services. “Farm income and employment are small shares of the rural economy almost everywhere in the United States,” according to the AEI experts. “Even with multiplier impacts that affect nonfarm employment and income opportunities, farm subsidies do little for rural poverty.” Farm workers, rural residents, and others in farm-related occupations receive little additional income from farm programs, the experts wrote. Despite warnings of a “farm crisis,” farm household income is still growing – even as the price of some bulk commodities return to normal. The USDA projects that median farm household income is $20,000 higher than that of non-farm households. Large and very large commercial farms reported median household incomes of $340,000 and $1.1 million, respectively, in 2015. Most farm households do not face the risk of poverty, according to the new AEI paper: “If the goal is to reduce poverty in the United States, focusing on farm operator households is unlikely to have much impact.” Many of the counties that receive the most subsidies are also among the counties with the nation’s highest levels of poverty and diet-related disease. Moreover, farm workers, who earn about $9 an hour, tend to pick fruit and vegetable crops that do not benefit from the lion’s share of farm subsidies. So do farm subsidies reduce rural poverty? According to the experts, the USDA does “many things to promote rural development,” such as offer loans to upgrade wastewater utilities, “but the agriculture subsidy programs are not central to that effort.” The reason why is clear: Most subsidies flow to the largest and most successful farm businesses, and have little impact on the rest of the rural economy. Source - http://www.ewg.org
18.11.2026

USA - News UH researchers use AI to prevent crop damage by predicting spread of invasive beetles

Researchers at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa are developing an artificial intelligence tool to protect agricultural lands by predicting where the invasive coconut rhinoceros beetle is most likely to spread.

18.11.2026

A hailstorm hit 5,600 hectares in Spain's Baix Maestrat, causing millions of euros in damage

Last Saturday's hailstorm and strong winds caused significant crop damage in the Baix Maestrat region of Castellón, particularly to citrus fruits.

18.11.2026

Czech vegetable growers face yield losses of 30 to 50% in worst-affected areas

Vegetable growers in Czechia have reported yield losses of 30 to 50 per cent in the worst-affected areas in 2026, according to the Vegetable Growers' Union of Bohemia and Moravia. 

18.11.2026

South Korea - Untreatable Tomato Virus Spreads Nationwide, Forcing Crop Destruction

A growing number of South Korean farms are being forced to destroy entire tomato crops just before harvest. Less than a month after an untreatable virus was detected in the country for the first time, it has spread nationwide, and damage in some areas is projected to exceed 10 billion won.

18.11.2026

Ireland - Weather-related potato crop failure left farmer with estimated €1m loss

A potato farmer has told an Oireachtas committee that devastating weather left him unable to harvest his crop, costing him an estimated €1 million in lost earnings.

18.11.2026

Kenya - Ruto says livestock insurance has covered 3.3 million animals to cushion pastoralists against drought losses

President William Ruto says more than 245,000 pastoralists have benefited from livestock insurance and savings incentives under a government programme designed to protect herds from drought-related losses.

12.11.2026

USA - Can crop insurance offer fishermen a better safety net?

For commercial fishermen, a sudden fishery closure can mean losing an entire season's income while bills keep coming. Vessel payments, insurance, moorage fees, and other operating expenses don't disappear when a fishery shuts down, and federal disaster assistance can take years to reach the people who need it.

12.11.2026

USA - Closing the Gap on Cotton Abandonment: The Case for a Harvest Incentive

Bart Fischer and Joe Outlaw write in Southern Ag Today: We all know that production agriculture is notoriously risky, with crop insurance having become the cornerstone of the farm safety net.