Australian farmers face tough decisions as crops fail

22.09.2024 468 views

Grain crops are failing in parts of the country due to dry weather and severe frosts.

Farmers are weighing up whether to cut them for hay instead of taking them through to harvest, but some crops are too poor even for hay.

Crops are running out of moisture in large parts of South Australia and north-west Victoria, where rainfall this growing season has been in the lowest 10 per cent on record.

On top of the dry conditions, some areas have also been smashed by severe frosts this week, which can damage plants and limit grain production.

Many farmers are concerned that if they don't receive decent rain soon, their crops will produce little grain.

Frosts smash already struggling crops

Crop assessor Marty Colbert said damage from three consecutive frosts would be "severe" in some regions.

"Our crop canopies aren't very big this year so the frost has plenty of opportunity to get in among it, and the consecutive days do have a cumulative effect," he said.

"I wouldn't be surprised if there could be 50 per cent losses, and we're not out of the frost window yet."

Frost on a windrower

Severe frosts in some regions has been the latest blow for grain growers. (Supplied: Pat Hallam)

Mr Colbert said in past seasons with mild springs and favourable rainfall, he had seen crops recover remarkably well from frost damage, but it would be a different story this season.

"I've seen crops completely recover, they just grow a whole new crop of fresh tillers and you'd wonder whether there'd ever been a frost," he said.

"But this year is the direct opposite of that, given we're all heading to the bottom of the barrel of moisture reserves, so these plants are already moisture-stressed and thus have very little potential for recovery."

Thinner by the day

Rick Plant, who farms at Cocamba in Victoria's Mallee, said his region was in desperate need of rain.

"We had 100 millimetres in the first week of January and ever since then we've been very dry all the way through," he said.

Dead crop

Crops in some regions are running out of moisture and dying. (Supplied: Rick Plant)

"Some areas are really tailing off and fizzling out and the crop is on its way to dying.

"Some of the crops that germinated early have held on pretty well, but anything that germinated late or is on heavier soil types has really struggled."

Rick Plant and his dog standing in his paddock

Some crops are performing better than others, but will still need more rain before the season is out. (Supplied: Natalie Plant)

If there's enough bulk in drought or frost-affected crops, they can be cut for hay, which could be a good option, given southern Australia's fodder stocks are low and hay prices are the highest they have been in several years.

But in some areas, crops are so poor that farmers can't justify the cost of cutting them for hay, nor do they want to leave the paddocks bare and run the risk of wind erosion over summer.

Mr Plant predicted grain yields could be as low as half a tonne to the hectare and would not cover costs.

"I think any crop that's still hanging in alright will make grain and the poorer crops don't have enough bulk to make it worthwhile, I just don't think it would be economical," he said.

Farmer Rick Plant in a paddock with his dog

Crops in the Victorian Mallee are hitting the wall as they run out of moisture. (Supplied: Natalie Plant)

Confronting situation

Joel Pymer is a young farmer and hay contractor from Wonwondah, south of Horsham in the Wimmera.

He recently took his windrower north to a farm near Swan Hill to cut a failed canola crop for hay.

"I hadn't been up there for a while so it was quite confronting really," he said.

"The crops on the sandier soil types seem to be going alright in spots, but they're really struggling on the heavier soil types."

Windrower in a failed canola crop

In a good season, this canola crop could have been chest high. (Supplied: Joel Pymer)

Even by windrowing the canola in 24 metre swathes, Mr Pymer said there still wasn't much biomass.

"It's a tough decision for many farmers, whether to cut or not cut those failed crops," he said.

Weather models not helping

Agriculture Victoria seasonal risk agronomist Dale Grey said despite weather models predicting rain, it just wasn't materialising.

"It's been a cow of a year for climate prediction," he said.

"We still have half the models predicting a wetter possibility for spring, and the other half sitting on the fence and saying anything could happen, and that's been going on for months.

"And rain is not manifesting, we're just getting these drier months, so my confidence is shot, I'm not believing these models at all."

A man with an Agriculture Victoria shirt on leaning on a fence post over a cloudy sky

Dale Grey says weather forecasting this season has been tough. (ABC Wodonga: Annie Brown)

Mr Grey advised farmers to make decisions — like whether to cut crops for hay — based on the conditions in front of them, rather than what long-term forecasts were saying.

"I think people need to be making decisions based on what they can see and measure, what soil moisture they have … rather than making a decision based on what a forecast may be saying," he said.

"Some years, the forecasts are not useful, that's a fact, and this year looks like one of those."

Huge input costs

Mr Plant said he and other farmers were facing big losses this season after spending heavily on inputs like fertiliser and putting faith in good subsoil moisture and a promising long-term rainfall outlook.

"I think the issue we've had this year is the fact we've had subsoil moisture and the rainfall outlook was pretty good so people have spent up on their crops to capitalise on that; a fair bit of urea has gone out, but we just haven't had the rain," he said.

"It's been an expensive crop to not have a great deal of prospects at the end."

small white urea pellets spill form an augur into a large trailer as a woman watches from the side

Farmers hopeful of a good season have spent up big on inputs like urea, but face making little money back. (ABC Rural: Clint Jasper)

It costs several hundred dollars per hectare to grow crops, irrespective of yields, so wheat yields below one tonne to the hectare would be unlikely to cover costs.

But Mr Plant said tough seasons were part of life in the Mallee.

"That's farming I suppose," he said.

"It's happened before and it will happen again — we live in hope, that's the reality of being a farmer."

Source - abc.net.au

20.04.2026

Pakistani mango crop declines on heat, cold, and hail damage

Mango production in Pakistan is expected to remain below normal this season due to weather-related impacts affecting flowering and fruit set in Punjab.

20.04.2026

Nepal - Minister Geeta Chaudhary Engages with Banana Farmers to Address Agricultural Challenges

Minister of Agriculture and Livestock Development and Minister of Forests and Environment, Geeta Chaudhary, has held a meeting with banana farmers. During the meeting, Minister Chaudhary discussed issues related to banana production, marketing, and fertilizer supply.

20.04.2026

Nigeria - Reps tackle NAIC, insurance firms over ₦1.12tn anchor borrowers’ fund

The House of Representatives Committee on Nutrition and Food Security has commenced an investigation into the insurance component of the ₦ 1.12 trillion Anchor Borrowers’ Programme, as part of a broader probe into alleged mismanagement and diversion of agricultural intervention funds.

20.04.2026

India - Canal Overflow Destroys 40 Acres of Crops in Narmadapuram, Farmers Face Heavy Loss

Narmadapuram canal overflow damages 40 acres of crops as irrigation failure leaves farmers facing heavy losses and rising concerns.

20.04.2026

India - Phek vets, farmers trained on livestock insurance under NLM

The Department of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Services, Phek, conducted a training programme on the Livestock Insurance Scheme for para-veterinarians and farmers under the National Livestock Mission (NLM) 2025–26 on April 13 at the office of the Chief Veterinary Officer (CVO), Phek.

20.04.2026

Philippines - CARD Pioneer shows the world how microinsurance works in PH through community immersion

Pioneer Insurance, with its joint venture CARD Pioneer Microinsurance Inc., brought global microinsurance leaders to an immersion in a farming community in Sta. Ana, Pampanga, giving them a firsthand look at how inclusive insurance works in communities and how it reaches farmers and underserved families.

19.04.2026

India - Fruit growers press for crop insurance, MIS revival

Responding to the concerns, Minister Javid Ahmad Dar, who chaired the meeting, assured the delegation that all issues would be examined and addressed in a phased and time-bound manner.

19.04.2026

Canada - How Saskatchewan’s satellite forage insurance program is going to work

Saskatchewan Crop Insurance Company shared some of the in-depth details ahead of the program’s inaugral year during the Sask. Stock Grower Association’s semi-annual meeting.