A potato farmer has told an Oireachtas committee that devastating weather left him unable to harvest his crop, costing him an estimated €1 million in lost earnings.
Jack Kingston, who appeared before the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food - alongside his father, John - said they had a total 120 acres of potatoes in the ground in 2023 - but relentless rain had a "devasating impact on the crop".
He told TDs and senators today (Wednesday, November 18) that the potatoes were grown on leased land during what Met Éireann recorded as one of the wettest years on record.
"We could not get in to harvest the crop due to saturated ground conditions.
"This continued into January 2024. Then approx from the 12th to 17th of January we got severe frosty nights, temperatures got down as low as -8 degrees Celsius," Jack Kingston said.
He outlined to the committee that according to figures compiled by Teagasc to grow an acre of potatoes cost between €4,500–€5,000 an acre approximately.
In relation to his 2023 crop he said: "Our costs combined for 120 acres come to €571,830 approx.
"With a calculated loss of earnings of €1,092,000".
Kingston told the committee this financial loss has "had a devastating impact on my ability to grow any crop".
He also said he has had no income "since the weather event".
Crop failure
Kingston said he sought compensation for the losses he suffered but he was unable to find any help.
This was despite, he told the committee, the Irish government securing over €7 million from the EU Agricultural Reserve forthe tillage sector and also matched this with €7 million in State funding.
Kingston said "part of that money was used to compensate tillage farmers whose crops could not be harvested because of the wet weather".
"I have no objection whatsoever to those farmers receiving assistance.
"They suffered genuine losses and deserved support. But potato growers were suffering losses from the same weather. So why were we treated differently," he asked.
According to the farmer the Department of Agriculture, Food the Marine (DAFM) repeatedly told him that "97% of the national potato crop was harvested and that the potato sector overall remained relatively strong".
But he told TDs and senators that "if 97% of the potatoes were harvested nationally, that does not put money into thepocket of the farmer whose crop was left rotting in the ground".
Compensation
Kingston, with the support of the Independent Ireland, Michael Fitzmaurice, said he has "spent considerable timetrying to establish why potato growers were excluded from compensation".
He said there was "a mechanism for helping individual farmers who suffered exceptional losses" even where the entire sector had not lost its crop.
But despite his efforts he has not been able to find out why potato growers "suffering comparable losses were not considered forsimilar support".
Kingston has now asked the committee to help him get answers to three questions:
1: "When did DAFM know how badly individual potato growers had been affected?"
2: "What assessment was carried out to determine whether those growers could receive exceptional support, and who made the decision that they should not?"
3: "Why was the approach used to compensate unharvested tillage crops not considered for potato growers?"
Kingston told the commitee that he is not looking for special treatment.
"I am asking for fair treatment, for transparency and for a proper explanation of decisions that have had serious consequences for farming families," he said.
Source - https://www.agriland.ie
